FIRST GAY CASTING! Cali Jock Deepthroats & Dicked Down By Muscle 42 min
42 minGay Castings - -
NextDoorStudios - Hot Hunk Fratboys First Time Secret Fuck 32 min
32 minNextDoorStudios Official - -
Ken, Nate, and Jackson - Three hot studs! What a cum dripping combo! Now in 2K 1080p :) 21 min
21 minAmateur Straight Guys - -
The first time of Magic Javi 10 min
10 minBLESSEXXX GAY - -
hot straight guy guy get a nice blowjob after a long time 12 min
12 minSt8guys 2022 - -
THE FIRST TIME OF THE BRAND NEW STRAIGHT 23 min
23 minPrentelhos - -
Straight caught by his gay friend for the first time - Puto Payo & Kevin Rodri 18 min
18 minBLESSEXXX GAY - -
First appearance! Athletic 21-year-old [Kensei] gets a super erection after experiencing a man for the first time in his life! A straight guy with outstanding sensitivity feels agonizing pleasure from anal stimulation! He is about to cum! hi 25 min
25 minCapy - -
James, Dylan & Cameron in 2K! 15 min
15 minAmateur Straight Guys - -
**The Lost Vegas Tapes** (3 Boys in a Bed, Bryan&Trevor, Cypher&Trevor, BryanCypher&Trevor Cricle Jerk) PLUS Another CircleJerk with Shaggy, Nectar, & Craig AND CK & Craig! And Trevor's Audition Vid! ALL IN 2K! (Remastered 2022) 1 h 55 min
1 h 55 minAmateur Straight Guys - -
Behind the full scene of sexy straight guys fucking each other 58 min
58 minSt8guys 2022 - -
Straight guy tried butt and loved it 21 min
21 minIrmaosdotados - -
Cute Sk8r Boy Seth Knight Meets W/ His Muscle Hunk Grindr Date For 1st Anal 20 min
20 minThick And Big - -
BAITBUS - It’s Not Gay The First Time, Or So We Told Him Haha 40 min
40 minBait Bus - -
Four of Bryan's Best PLUS a BONUS - Cabin Four Way!! In 2K!! 78 min
78 minAmateur Straight Guys - -
Taking straight guys cherry 23 min
23 minIrishStr8Huntr - -
My STRAIGHT friend tries a COCK for the first time 11 min
11 minZEUS RAY - -
MMA fighter fucks a silicone vagina for the first time and ends up inside 9 min
9 minSerejke1992 - -
Hot str8 Dancer gets blowjob for first time 16 min
16 minSt8guys 2022 - -
Out of work businessman sucks and rides cock for money 20 min
20 minMale Dream - -
STRAIGHT SEDUCED! Military Recruit Gets First Anal Massage After Boot Camp 25 min
25 minMassage Bait - -
Four Hot Fucks Starring Brent Corrigan (and he gers DP'd)!!! (2K/1080p) 1 h 36 min
1 h 36 minDirty Bird Pictures - -
Hot Jock Goes Balls Deep Into His Straight Friend's Super Tight Asshole 25 min
25 minManroyale - -
Blain & Beau - Two sexy straight studs get it on! 2K 1080p! (Remastered 2022) 35 min
35 minAmateur Straight Guys - -
FULL VIDEO: Straight British student tries gay sex for the first time 7 min
7 minLeoTeenLatinos - -
Straight Boy Takes a Seat On a Dildo for the first time 8 min
8 minStraightstoner - -
Straight Dutch student tries gay sex for the first time (FULL VIDEO) - "Reinder" 7 min
